Critical issues presentations/Dataism vs/and Humanism. What Wikipedia will born in the future?

From Wikimania 2016 • Esino Lario, Italy
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Submission no. 134
Title of the submission

Dataism vs/and Humanism. What Wikipedia will born in the future?

Author of the submission
  • Salvador Alcántar
Country of origin

Mexico

Topics

other, Projects

Keywords
  • Data
  • humanism
  • dataism
  • community
  • Wikipedia
  • future of projects.
Abstract

Currently there is a fashion that make emphasis in the use of data to improve and create content in Wikipedia. That fashion is a reflect of a modern world-spread cult to the data. Data is useful and is mining deep in our behavior as Wikipedians. The developing of tools as Ores and bot-created articles maybe will make unnecessary the help of humand hands.

On the other hand Wikipedia in it's own nature, as an enciclopedy, is the heir of a tradition of humanism coming from XVII century and before. Many Wikipedians work based on that idea. Actually, the beggining of Wikipedia and the appropiation of the project by the community lays mainly in a humanist feeling.

This interpretations of what Wikipedia is and does are starting to fight one against other.

My talk would be a philosophical reflexion about this two Wikipedia interpretations in conflict. And attempt of aware the community of what the future of Wikipedia could be if one of both understandings wins over the other and what if two work altogether. Can Wikipedia become a robot where community doesn't matter? The future Wikimedian will be only a feeder of hard data and not a reader and writter?

Result

Not accepted